Unpopular opinion: Open concept daycares are one of the worse environments to socialize dogs.
Updated: 5 days ago
Before anyone assumes I'm saying this without experience, I started working in the dog daycare and boarding industry in 2005, when I was just 15 years old.
I've spent over two decades working professionally with dogs, and a significant part of my early career was spent working in multiple daycare and boarding facilities.
I've seen firsthand how dogs interact in large groups, how their behaviour changes over time, and how environments that are intended to provide socialization can sometimes contribute to the very behavioural issues owners are trying to prevent.
My opinion isn't coming from someone who has never worked in daycare or doesn't understand how these facilities operate. It's coming from years of hands on experience, observation, and a much deeper understanding of canine behaviour than I had when I first entered the industry.
And the more I've learned about dogs, the less I believe that unrestricted group play is beneficial for every dog.
Somewhere along the way, we decided that throwing a bunch of dogs into a room together for hours of unrestricted social interaction was a great way to socialize them. But what are we actually teaching them?
Overarousal, frustration, and the expectation that every dog they see is an opportunity for interaction.
Think about it.
A dog spends hours at daycare running, wrestling, chasing, barking, and interacting with other dogs whenever it wants. Every dog becomes a source of excitement, stimulation, and reinforcement.
Now take that same dog out for a walk.
Suddenly, there's a leash, a handler, boundaries. That dog across the street? They can't run over and say hello.
And what happens when a dog that has repeatedly been rewarded for accessing other dogs suddenly can't?
Frustration.
Barking, lunging, pulling, screaming, and what many owners eventually describe as leash reactivity.
This is often referred to as barrier frustration or leash aggression and while daycare isn't the only contributing factor, environments that constantly reinforce unrestricted access to other dogs can make these behaviours worse.
But here's another issue that doesn't get talked about enough. Some dogs don't even LIKE daycare.
Not every dog enjoys being surrounded by other dogs for hours on end. Some are socially selective, some are easily overwhelmed, and some simply don't want to interact with other dogs.
Yet they're placed in a room with multiple dogs, often with no real opportunity to escape the social pressure. They can't remove themselves from the environment, find a quiet space to decompress, or get away from dogs that continually approach them.
Imagine being forced to spend eight hours in a crowded room with people constantly invading your personal space, and having absolutely nowhere to go when you've had enough.
Now imagine that happening multiple days a week.
For some dogs, this creates an enormous amount of stress, frustration, and emotional exhaustion.
And here's something owners need to understand.
Just because your dog comes home exhausted from daycare doesn't mean they had a good time.
We constantly hear people say, "My dog LOVES daycare! He comes home and sleeps for the rest of the night!" But is your dog tired because they had a fulfilling day, or are they completely exhausted from spending hours in a stressful, overstimulating environment?
Those are two very different things. Stress is exhausting. Constantly navigating social interactions, managing unwanted attention, and being unable to disengage can be mentally and physically draining.
A dog that comes home and crashes isn't automatically a happy dog, and this is where things can become even more problematic.
When dogs are repeatedly put into situations where they feel uncomfortable and cannot create distance, frustration and defensive behaviours can begin to develop.
A dog that initially tried to avoid interactions may eventually learn that barking, growling, snapping, or lunging is the only way to get another dog to back off.
Over time, those experiences can contribute to outward reactivity toward other dogs, including on leash.
Instead of seeing another dog as something neutral, they may begin anticipating unwanted interactions, stress, or conflict.
So now we have two very different dogs potentially developing similar reactive behaviours.
One dog becomes frustrated because it's accustomed to having unrestricted access to every dog it sees.
The other becomes reactive because it's learned that other dogs are overwhelming, stressful, and difficult to escape.
Two different emotional responses, but both can be made worse by poorly managed daycare environments.
And neither is what we should be aiming for when we talk about healthy socialization.
Socialization is NOT about interacting with every dog you see.
It's about learning how to exist in the world without needing to engage with everything in it.
A well socialized dog should be able to walk past another dog without losing its mind. It should be able to settle in the presence of other dogs, disengage from exciting situations, and understand that not every interaction is available to them.
Not every dog needs dog friends. Not every dog enjoys group play. And not every dog is suited for a daycare environment.
A good daycare should recognize that and respect the individual dog's needs rather than expecting every dog to fit into the same environment.
And to be clear, I'm not saying every open concept daycare is terrible or that every dog attending one will develop behavioural issues. There are dogs that genuinely enjoy group play and facilities that do a good job managing their groups.
But after spending so many years working with dogs, I strongly believe we need to stop treating daycare as a one size fits all solution and start paying more attention to what each individual dog actually needs.
Stop confusing constant social interaction with healthy socialization.
A tired dog isn't necessarily a fulfilled dog. An exhausted dog isn't necessarily a happy dog. And a dog that tolerates an environment isn't necessarily enjoying it.
Excitement is easy to create. Teaching a dog how to come back down, respect boundaries, and feel comfortable doing absolutely nothing is where the real training happens.




Comments